I had the opportunity to see the Judd Apatow movie on DVD last night. Big thanks to Melissa for suggesting it and sitting through it.
Judd’s fingerprints are all over this, and it is very similar in style and presentation to the 40 year old virgin. That format lends itself perfectly to the dialogue of stand up comics conversing amongst themselves. Judd really nailed the vibe and style that comes from comics talking to comics, and I felt at home with all the characters.
The failing of the movie was biting off too much source material to chew. Judd (rightly) wants to capture all the comedic gold that comes from this talented cast just riffing and improving with each other. The result is a VERY long movie that drags itself to the finish line over the final 20 minutes. You sincerely want to see the happily ever after ending, and you emotionally invest in the story, but wow do they take their time getting there.
I think Adam Sandler really missed an opportunity here. Very rarely does a main character go through so dramatic an arc as to be faced with a terminal disease, recover, contact ‘the girl that got away’, discover himself, discover the value of family and friends, and in the end grow up to be a better man. Adam plays each phase of this amazing plot the same way, so you never really get the sense that he’s THAT sick, or THAT sorry, or THAT lonely. He’s capable of much more and I was disappointed.
Seth Rogen is once again playing himself, and he is only a name swap away from Pineapple Express or Knocked Up. This movie was the perfect vehicle for that ‘character’ and I hope that Seth uses this as a closer to this style and takes the opportunity to grow as an actor. He definitely has the chops but he seems unwilling to venture out of his comfortable supporting cast and situations.
I did find myself laughing, but it’s a series of good small funny spots with no real topper. The comedy doesn’t quite support the weight of the drama, and the drama isn’t strong enough on it’s own to survive without the comedy. The spots where stand-up comics were cutting on each other were by far the best. I think I enjoyed this movie more than the average movie goer would, my ability to relate to the material and style being much greater.
Good rent, don’t buy. Funny People 3 meaningless icon symbols of your choice out of 5